to the Royal Society； Mr。 Gilbert refused to allow it to be filled up； on the ground that he should not be President next year； and had made no vacancy。
Next year Mr。 Gilbert wished again to be President one other year； but the Board of Longitude was dissolved； otherwise we might have had some LOCUM TENENS to retire at Mr。 Gilbert's pleasure。
These circumstances are in themselves of trifling importance； but they illustrate the character of the proceedings： and it is not becoming the dignity of science or of the Society that its officers should be so circumstanced as to have an apparent and direct interest in supporting the existing President； in order to retain their own places； and if such a system is once discovered； doubt immediately arises as to the frequency of such arrangements。
SECTION 3。
OF THE SECRETARISHIPS。
Whether the present Secretaries are the best qualified to aid in reforming the Society； is a question I shall not discuss。 With regard to the senior Secretary； the time of his holding office is perhaps more unfortunate than the circumstance。 If I might be permitted to allude for a moment to his personal character； I should say that the mild excellencies of his heart have prevented the Royal Society from deriving the whole of that advantage from his varied knowledge and liberal sentiments which some might perhaps have anticipated； and many will agree with me in regretting that his judgment has not directed a larger portion of the past deeds of the Councils of the Royal Society。 Of the junior Secretary I shall only observe； that whilst I admit his industry； his perseverance； and his talents； I regret to see such valuable qualities exerted at a disadvantage； and that I sincerely wish them all the success they merit in situations more adapted for their developement。
There are； however； some general principles which it may be important to investigate； which relate to the future as well as to the past state of the office of Secretary of the Royal Society。 Inconvenience has already arisen from having had at a former period one of our Secretaries the conductor of a scientific journal； and this is one of the points in which I can agree with those who now manage the affairs of the Society。 ＇These observations were written previous to the late appointment； to which I now devote Section 6。 Experience seems to be lost on the Council of the Royal Society。＇ Perhaps it might be advantageous to extend the same understanding to the other officers of the Society at least； if not to the members of its Council。
Another circumstance worthy of the attention of the Society is； to consider whether it is desirable； except in special cases； to have military persons appointed to any of its offices。 There are several peculiarities in the military character； which； though they do not absolutely unfit their possessors for the individual prosecution of science； may in some degree disqualify such persons from holding offices in scientific institutions。 The habits both of obedience and command； which are essential in military life； are little fitted for that perfect freedom which should reign in the councils of science。 If a military chief commit an oversight or an error； it is necessary； in order to retain the confidence of those he commands； to conceal or mask it as much as possible。 If an experimentalist make a mistake； his only course to win the confidence of his fellow…labourers in science； and to render his future observations of any use； is to acknowledge it in the most full and explicit manner。 The very qualifications which contribute to the professional excellence of the soldier； constitute his defects when he enters the paths of science； and it is only in those rare cases where the force of genius is able to control and surmount these habits； that his admission to the offices of science can be attended with any advantage to it。
Another objection deserving notice； although not applying exclusively to the military profession； is； that persons not imbued with the feelings of men of science； when they have published their observations； are too apt to view every criticism upon them as a personal question； and to consider that it is as offensive to doubt the accuracy of their observations as it is to doubt their word。 Nothing can be more injurious to science than that such an opinion should be tolerated。 The most unreserved criticism is necessary for truth； and those suspicions respecting his own accuracy； which every philosophical experimenter will entertain concerning his own researches； ought never to be considered as a reproach； when they are kept in view in examining the experiments of others。 The minute circumstances and apparently trivial causes which lend their influence towards error； even in persons of the most candid judgment； are amongst the most curious phenomena of the human mind。
The importance of affording every aid to enable others to try the merits of observations； has been so well expressed by Mayer； that I shall conclude these remarks with an extract from the Preface to his Observations：
〃Officii enim cujusque observatoris ease reor； de habitu instrumenti sui； de cura ac precautione； qua usus est； ad illud recte tractandum； deque mediis in errores ejus inquirendi rationem reddere publice； ut aliis quoque copia sit judicandi； quanta fides habenda conclusionibus ex nostris observationibus deductis aut deducendis。 Hoc cum minus fecissent precedentis saeculi astronomi； praxin nimis secure； nimisque theoretice tractantes； factum inde potissimum est； ut illorum observationes tot vigiliis tantoque labore comparatae tam cito obsoleverint。〃 P。 viii。
There are certain duties which the Royal Society owes to its own character as well as to the public； which； having been on some occasions apparently neglected； it may be here the proper place to mention； since it is reasonable to suppose that attention to them is within the province of its Secretaries。
The first to which I shall allude is the singular circumstances attending the fact of the Royal Society having printed a volume of Astronomical Observations which were made at the Observatory of Paramatta （New South Wales）； bearing the title of 〃The Third Part of the Philosophical Transactions for the Year 1829。〃
Now this Observatory was founded at the private expense of a British officer； the instruments were paid for out of his purse； two observers were brought from Europe； to be employed in making use of those instruments； at salaries defrayed by him。 A considerable portion of the observations so printed were made by these astronomers during their employment in his service； and some of them are personally his own。 Yet has the Royal Society； in adopting them as part of its Transactions； omitted all mention； either in their title…page； preface； or in any part of the volume； of the FACT that the world owed these valuable observations to the enlightened munificence of Lieutenant…General Sir Thomas Brisbane； whose ardent zeal in the pursuit of science induced him to found； at his own private expense； an establishment which it has been creditable to the British Government to continue as a national institution。 Had any kindred feelings existed in the Council； instead of endeavouring to shift the responsibility； they would have hastened to rectify an omission； less unjust to the individual than it was injurious to English science。
Another topic； which concerns most vitally the character and integrity of the Royal Society； I hardly know how to approach。 It has been publicly stated that confidence cannot be placed in the written minutes of the Society； and an instance has been adduced； in which an entry has been asserted to have been made； which could not have been the true statement of what actually passed at the Council。
The facts on which the specific instance rests are not difficult to verify by members of the Royal Society。 I have examined them； and shall state them before I enter on the reasoning which may be founded upon them。 In the minutes of the Council； 26th November； 1829； we find
〃Resolved； that the following gentlemen be recommended to be put upon the Council for the ensuing year。〃 ＇Here follows a list of persons； amongst whom the name of Sir John Franklin occurs ＇Sir John Franklin was absent from London； and altogether unacquainted with this transaction； until he saw it stated in the newspapers some months after it had taken place。 That his name was the one substituted for that of Captain Beaufort I know； from other evidence which need not be produced here； as the omission of the latter name is the charge that has been made。＇； and that of Captain Beaufort is not found。 ＇Any gentleman may satisfy himself that this is not a mistake of the Assistant Secretary's； in copying； by consulting the rough minutes of that meeting of the Council； which it might perhaps be as well to write in a rough minute…book； instead of upon loose sheets of paper； nor can it be attributed to any error arising from accidentally mislaying the real minutes； for in that case the error would have been rectified immediately it was detected； and this has remained uncorrected； although publicly spoken of for months。 As there is no erasure in the list； one is reluctantly compelled to conjecture that the real minutes of that meeting have been destroyed。＇＇
Now this could not be the list actually recommended by the Council on the morning of the 26th of November； because the President himself； on the evening of that day； informed Capt。 Beaufort that he was placed on the house list； and that officer； with the characteristic openness of his profession； wrote on the next or the following day to the President； declining that situation； and stating his reasons for the step。
Upon the fact； therefore； of the suppression of part of a resolution of the Council； on the 26th of November； there can be no doubt； but in order to understand the whole nature of the transaction； other information is necessary。 It has been the wish of many members of the Society； that the President should not absolutely name his own Council； but that the subject should be discussed fairly at the meeting previous to the Anniversary this has always been opposed by Mr。 Gilbert； and those who