darwin and modern science- 第76部分

These　examples　may　suffice　to　indicate　that　the　arrangement　of　definite　groups　of　cells　and　the　morphological　effects　resulting　therefrom　may　be　determined　by　forces　lying　outside　the　cells。　　Since　these　forces　are　ubiquitous　and　constant　it　appears　as　if　we　were　dealing　exclusively　with　the　influence　of　a　gamete；　while　in　reality　all　that　it　is　necessary　for　the　gamete　to　transmit　is　a　certain　form　of　irritability。

（d）　　FACTORS　WHICH　DETERMINE　PLACE　AND　TIME　FOR　THE　DEPOSITION　OF　EGGS。

For　the　preservation　of　species　the　instinct　of　animals　to　lay　their　eggs　in　places　in　which　the　young　larvae　find　their　food　and　can　develop　is　of　paramount　importance。　　A　simple　example　of　this　instinct　is　the　fact　that　the　common　fly　lays　its　eggs　on　putrid　material　which　serves　as　food　for　the　young　larvae。　　When　a　piece　of　meat　and　of　fat　of　the　same　animal　are　placed　side　by　side；　the　fly　will　deposit　its　eggs　upon　the　meat　on　which　the　larvae　can　grow；　and　not　upon　the　fat；　on　which　they　would　starve。　　Here　we　are　dealing　with　the　effect　of　a　volatile　nitrogenous　substance　which　reflexly　causes　the　peristaltic　motions　for　the　laying　of　the　egg　in　the　female　fly。

Kammerer　has　investigated　the　conditions　for　the　laying　of　eggs　in　two　forms　of　salamanders；　e。g。　Salamandra　atra　and　S。　maculosa。　　In　both　forms　the　eggs　are　fertilised　in　the　body　and　begin　to　develop　in　the　uterus。　　Since　there　is　room　only　for　a　few　larvae　in　the　uterus；　a　large　number　of　eggs　perish　and　this　number　is　the　greater　the　longer　the　period　of　gestation。　　It　thus　happens　that　when　the　animals　retain　their　eggs　a　long　time；　very　few　young　ones　are　born；　and　these　are　in　a　rather　advanced　stage　of　development；　owing　to　the　long　time　which　elapsed　since　they　were　fertilised。　　When　the　animal　lays　its　eggs　comparatively　soon　after　copulation；　many　eggs　（from　12　to　72）　are　produced　and　the　larvae　are　of　course　in　an　early　stage　of　development。　　In　the　early　stage　the　larvae　possess　gills　and　can　therefore　live　in　water；　while　in　later　stages　they　have　no　gills　and　breathe　through　their　lungs。　　Kammerer　showed　that　both　forms　of　Salamandra　can　be　induced　to　lay　their　eggs　early　or　late；　according　to　the　physical　conditions　surrounding　them。　　If　they　are　kept　in　water　or　in　proximity　to　water　and　in　a　moist　atmosphere　they　have　a　tendency　to　lay　their　eggs　earlier　and　a　comparatively　high　temperature　enhances　the　tendency　to　shorten　the　period　of　gestation。　　If　the　salamanders　are　kept　in　comparative　dryness　they　show　a　tendency　to　lay　their　eggs　rather　late　and　a　low　temperature　enhances　this　tendency。

Since　Salamandra　atra　is　found　in　rather　dry　alpine　regions　with　a　relatively　low　temperature　and　Salamandra　maculosa　in　lower　regions　with　plenty　of　water　and　a　higher　temperature；　the　fact　that　S。　atra　bears　young　which　are　already　developed　and　beyond　the　stage　of　aquatic　life；　while　S。　maculosa　bears　young　ones　in　an　earlier　stage；　has　been　termed　adaptation。　　Kammerer's　experiments；　however；　show　that　we　are　dealing　with　the　direct　effects　of　definite　outside　forces。　　While　we　may　speak　of　adaptation　when　all　or　some　of　the　variables　which　determine　a　reaction　are　unknown；　it　is　obviously　in　the　interest　of　further　scientific　progress　to　connect　cause　and　effect　directly　whenever　our　knowledge　allows　us　to　do　so。

VII。　　CONCLUDING　REMARKS。

The　discovery　of　De　Vries；　that　new　species　may　arise　by　mutation　and　the　wide　if　not　universal　applicability　of　Mendel's　Law　to　phenomena　of　heredity；　as　shown　especially　by　Bateson　and　his　pupils；　must；　for　the　time　being；　if　not　permanently；　serve　as　a　basis　for　theories　of　evolution。　　These　discoveries　place　before　the　experimental　biologist　the　definite　task　of　producing　mutations　by　physico…chemical　means。　　It　is　true　that　certain　authors　claim　to　have　succeeded　in　this；　but　the　writer　wishes　to　apologise　to　these　authors　for　his　inability　to　convince　himself　of　the　validity　of　their　claims　at　the　present　moment。　　He　thinks　that　only　continued　breeding　of　these　apparent　mutants　through　several　generations　can　afford　convincing　evidence　that　we　are　here　dealing　with　mutants　rather　than　with　merely　pathological　variations。

What　was　said　in　regard　to　the　production　of　new　species　by　physico…　chemical　means　may　be　repeated　with　still　more　justification　in　regard　to　the　second　problem　of　transformation；　namely　the　making　of　living　from　inanimate　matter。　　The　purely　morphological　imitations　of　bacteria　or　cells　which　physicists　have　now　and　then　proclaimed　as　artificially　produced　living　beings；　or　the　plays　on　words　by　which；　e。g。　the　regeneration　of　broken　crystals　and　the　regeneration　of　lost　limbs　by　a　crustacean　were　declared　identical；　will　not　appeal　to　the　biologist。　　We　know　that　growth　and　development　in　animals　and　plants　are　determined　by　definite　although　complicated　series　of　catenary　chemical　reactions；　which　result　in　the　synthesis　of　a　DEFINITE　compound　or　group　of　compounds；　namely；　NUCLEINS。

The　nucleins　have　the　peculiarity　of　acting　as　ferments　or　enzymes　for　their　own　synthesis。　　Thus　a　given　type　of　nucleus　will　continue　to　synthesise　other　nuclein　of　its　own　kind。　　This　determines　the　continuity　of　a　species；　since　each　species　has；　probably；　its　own　specific　nuclein　or　nuclear　material。　　But　it　also　shows　us　that　whoever　claims　to　have　succeeded　in　making　living　matter　from　inanimate　will　have　to　prove　that　he　has　succeeded　in　producing　nuclein　material　which　acts　as　a　ferment　for　its　own　synthesis　and　thus　reproduces　itself。　　Nobody　has　thus　far　succeeded　in　this；　although　nothing　warrants　us　in　taking　it　for　granted　that　this　task　is　beyond　the　power　of　science。

XV。　　THE　VALUE　OF　COLOUR　IN　THE　STRUGGLE　FOR　LIFE。

By　E。B。　POULTON。　Hope　Professor　of　Zoology　in　the　University　of　Oxford。

INTRODUCTION。

The　following　pages　have　been　written　almost　entirely　from　the　historical　stand…point。　　Their　principal　object　has　been　to　give　some　account　of　the　impressions　produced　on　the　mind　of　Darwin　and　his　great　compeer　Wallace　by　various　difficult　problems　suggested　by　the　colours　of　living　nature。　　In　order　to　render　the　brief　summary　of　Darwin's　thoughts　and　opinions　on　the　subject　in　any　way　complete；　it　was　found　necessary　to　say　again　much　that　has　often　been　said　before。　　No　attempt　has　been　made　to　display　as　a　whole　the　vast　contribution　of　Wallace；　but　certain　of　its　features　are　incidentally　revealed　in　passages　quoted　from　Darwin's　letters。　　It　is　assumed　that　the　reader　is　familiar　with　the　well…known　theories　of　Protective　Resemblance；　Warning　Colours；　and　Mimicry　both　Batesian　and　Mullerian。　　It　would　have　been　superfluous　to　explain　these　on　the　present　occasion；　for　a　far　more　detailed　account　than　could　have　been　attempted　in　these　pages　has　recently　appeared。　　（Poulton；　〃Essays　on　Evolution〃　Oxford；　1908；　pages　293…382。）　　Among　the　older　records　I　have　made　a　point　of　bringing　together　the　principal　observations　scattered　through　the　note…　books　and　collections　of　W。J。　Burchell。　　These　have　never　hitherto　found　a　place　in　any　memoir　dealing　with　the　significance　of　the　colours　of　animals。

INCIDENTAL　COLOURS。

Darwin　fully　recognised　that　the　colours　of　living　beings　are　not　necessarily　of　value　as　colours；　but　that　they　may　be　an　incidental　result　of　chemical　or　physical　structure。　　Thus　he　wrote　to　T。　Meehan；　Oct。　9；　1874：　　〃I　am　glad　that　you　are　attending　to　the　colours　of　dioecious　flowers；　but　it　is　well　to　remember　that　their　colours　may　be　as　unimportant　to　them　as　those　of　a　gall；　or；　indeed；　as　the　colour　of　an　amethyst　or　ruby　is　to　these　gems。〃　　（〃More　Letters　of　Charles　Darwin〃；　Vol。　I。　pages　354；　355。　　See　also　the　admirable　account　of　incidental　colours　in　〃Descent　of　Man〃　（2nd　edition）；　1874；　pages　261；　262。）

Incidental　colours　remain　as　available　assets　of　the　organism　ready　to　be　turned　to　account　by　natural　selection。　　It　is　a　probable　speculation　that　all　pigmentary　colours　were　originally　incidental；　but　now　and　for　immense　periods　of　time　the　visible　tints　of　animals　have　been　modified　and　arranged　so　as　to　assist　in　the　struggle　with　other　organisms　or　in　courtship。　　The　dominant　colouring　of　plants；　on　the　other　hand；　is　an　essential　element　in　the　paramount　physiological　activity　of　chlorophyll。　　In　exceptional　instances；　however；　the　shapes　and　visible　colours　of　plants　may　be　modified　in　order　to　promote　concealment。

TELEOLOGY　AND　ADAPTATION。

In　the　department　of　Biology　which　forms　the　subject　of　this　essay；　the　adaptation　of　means　to　an　end　is　probably　more　evident　than　in　any　other；　and　it　is　therefore　of　interest　to　compare；　in　a　brief　introductory　section；　the　older　with　the　newer　teleological　views。

The　distinctive　feature　of　Natural　Selection　as　contrasted　with　other　attempts　to　explain　the　process　of　Evolution　is　the　part　played　by　the　struggle　for　existence。　　All　naturalists　in　all　ages　must　have　known　something　of　the　operations　of　〃Nature　red　in　tooth　and　claw〃；　but　it　was　left　for　this　great　theory　to　suggest　that　vast　extermination　is　a　necessary　condition　of　progress；　and　even　of　maintaining　the　ground　already　gained。

Realising　that　fitness　is　the　outcome　of　this　fierce　struggle；　thus　turned　to　account　for　the　first　time；　we　are　sometimes　led　to　associate　the　recognition　of　adaptation　itself　too　exclusively　with　Natural　Selection。　　Adaptation　had　been　studied　with　the　warmest　enthusiasm　nearly　forty　years　before　this　great　theory　was　given　to　the　scientific　world；　and　it　is　difficult　now　to　realise　the　impetus　which　the　works　of　Paley　gave　to　the　study　of　Natural　History。　　That　they　did　inspire　the　naturalists　of　the　early　part　of　the　last　century　is　clearly　shown　in　the　following　passages。

In　the　year　1824　the　Ashmolean　Museum　at　Oxford　was　intrusted　to　the　care　of　J。S。　Duncan　of　New　College。　　He　was　succeeded　in　this　office　by　his　brother；　P。B。　Duncan；　of　the　same　College；　author　of　a　History　of　the　Museum；　which　shows　very　clearly　the　influence　of　Paley　upon　the　study　of　nature；　and　the　dominant　position　given　to　his　teachings：　　〃Happily　at　this　time　（1824）　a　taste　for　the　study　of　natural　history　had　been　excited　in　the　University　by　Dr　Paley's　very　interesting　work　on　Natural　Theology；　and　the　very　popular　lecture