les him to be considered the father of geology。 Thus Hippolytus records that Xenophanes studied the fossils to be found in quarries； and drew from their observation remarkable conclusions。 His words are as follows： 〃Xenophanes believes that once the earth was mingled with the sea； but in the course of time it became freed from moisture； and his proofs are such as these： that shells are found in the midst of the land and among the mountains； that in the quarries of Syracuse the imprints of a fish and of seals had been found； and in Paros the imprint of an anchovy at some depth in the stone； and in Melite shallow impressions of all sorts of sea products。 He says that these imprints were made when everything long ago was covered with mud； and then the imprint dried in the mud。 Further； he says that all men will be destroyed when the earth sinks into the sea and becomes mud； and that the race will begin anew from the beginning； and this transformation takes place for all worlds。〃＇7＇ Here； then； we see this earliest of paleontologists studying the fossil…bearing strata of the earth； and drawing from his observations a marvellously scientific induction。 Almost two thousand years later another famous citizen of Italy； Leonardo da Vinci； was independently to think out similar conclusions from like observations。 But not until the nineteenth century of our era； some twenty…four hundred years after the time of Xenophanes； was the old Greek's doctrine to be accepted by the scientific world。 The ideas of Xenophanes were known to his contemporaries and； as we see； quoted for a few centuries by his successors； then they were ignored or quite forgotten； and if any philosopher of an ensuing age before the time of Leonardo championed a like rational explanation of the fossils； we have no record of the fact。 The geological doctrine of Xenophanes； then； must be listed among those remarkable Greek anticipations of nineteenth …century science which suffered almost total eclipse in the intervening centuries。 Among the pupils of Xenophanes was Parmenides； the thinker who was destined to carry on the work of his master along the same scientific lines； though at the same time mingling his scientific conceptions with the mysticism of the poet。 We have already had occasion to mention that Parmenides championed the idea that the earth is round； noting also that doubts exist as to whether he or Pythagoras originated this doctrine。 No explicit answer to this question can possibly be hoped for。 It seems clear； however； that for a long time the Italic School； to which both these philosophers belonged； had a monopoly of the belief in question。 Parmenides； like Pythagoras； is credited with having believed in the motion of the earth； though the evidence furnished by the writings of the philosopher himself is not as demonstrative as one could wish。 Unfortunately； the copyists of a later age were more concerned with metaphysical speculations than with more tangible things。 But as far as the fragmentary references to the ideas of Parmenides may be accepted； they do not support the idea of the earth's motion。 Indeed； Parmenides is made to say explicitly； in preserved fragments； that 〃the world is immovable； limited； and spheroidal in form。〃＇8＇ Nevertheless； some modern interpreters have found an opposite meaning in Parmenides。 Thus Ritter interprets him as supposing 〃that the earth is in the centre spherical； and maintained in rotary motion by its equiponderance； around it lie certain rings； the highest composed of the rare element fire； the next lower a compound of light and darkness； and lowest of all one wholly of night； which probably indicated to his mind the surface of the earth； the centre of which again he probably considered to be fire。〃＇9＇ But this； like too many interpretations of ancient thought； appears to read into the fragments ideas which the words themselves do not warrant。 There seems no reason to doubt； however； that Parmenides actually held the doctrine of the earth's sphericity。 Another glimpse of his astronomical doctrines is furnished us by a fragment which tells us that he conceived the morning and the evening stars to be the same； a doctrine which； as we have seen； was ascribed also to Pythagoras。 Indeed； we may repeat that it is quite impossible to distinguish between the astronomical doctrines of these two philosophers。 The poem of Parmenides in which the cosmogonic speculations occur treats also of the origin of man。 The author seems to have had a clear conception that intelligence depends on bodily organism； and that the more elaborately developed the organism the higher the intelligence。 But in the interpretation of this thought we are hampered by the characteristic vagueness of expression； which may best be evidenced by putting before the reader two English translations of the same stanza。 Here is Ritter's rendering； as made into English by his translator； Morrison： 〃For exactly as each has the state of his limbs many…jointed； So invariably stands it with men in their mind and their reason； For the system of limbs is that which thinketh in mankind Alike in all and in each： for thought is the fulness。〃＇10＇ The same stanza is given thus by George Henry Lewes： 〃Such as to each man is the nature of his many…jointed limbs； Such also is the intelligence of each man； for it is The nature of limbs （organization） which thinketh in men； Both in one and in all； for the highest degree of organization gives the highest degree of thought。〃＇11＇
Here it will be observed that there is virtual agreement between the translators except as to the last clause； but that clause is most essential。 The Greek phrase is 。 Ritter； it will be observed； renders this； 〃for thought is the fulness。〃 Lewes paraphrases it； 〃for the highest degree of organization gives the highest degree of thought。〃 The difference is intentional； since Lewes himself criticises the translation of Ritter。 Ritter's translation is certainly the more literal； but the fact that such diversity is possible suggests one of the chief elements of uncertainty that hamper our interpretation of the thought of antiquity。 Unfortunately； the mind of the commentator has usually been directed towards such subtleties； rather than towards the expression of precise knowledge。 Hence it is that the philosophers of Greece are usually thought of as mere dreamers； and that their true status as scientific discoverers is so often overlooked。 With these intangibilities we have no present concern beyond this bare mention； for us it suffices to gain as clear an idea as we may of the really scientific conceptions of these thinkers； leaving the subtleties of their deductive reasoning for the most part untouched。
EMPEDOCLES The latest of the important pre…Socratic philosophers of the Italic school was Empedocles； who was born about 494 B。C。 and lived to the age of sixty。 These dates make Empedocles strictly contemporary with Anaxagoras； a fact which we shall do well to bear in mind when we come to consider the latter's philosophy in the succeeding chapter。 Like Pythagoras； Empedocles is an imposing figure。 Indeed； there is much of similarity between the personalities； as between the doctrines； of the two men。 Empedocles； like Pythagoras； was a physician； like him also he was the founder of a cult。 As statesman； prophet； physicist； physician； reformer； and poet he showed a versatility that； coupled with profundity； marks the highest genius。 In point of versatility we shall perhaps hardly find his equal at a later dayunless； indeed； an exception be made of Eratosthenes。 The myths that have grown about the name of Empedocles show that he was a remarkable personality。 He is said to have been an awe…inspiring figure； clothing himself in Oriental splendor and moving among mankind as a superior being。 Tradition has it that he threw himself into the crater of a volcano that his otherwise unexplained disappearance might lead his disciples to believe that he had been miraculously translated； but tradition goes on to say that one of the brazen slippers of the philosopher was thrown up by the volcano； thus revealing his subterfuge。 Another tradition of far more credible aspect asserts that Empedocles retreated from Italy； returning to the home of his fathers in Peloponnesus to die there obscurely。 It seems odd that the facts regarding the death of so great a man； at so comparatively late a period； should be obscure； but this； perhaps； is in keeping with the personality of the man himself。 His disciples would hesitate to ascribe a merely natural death to so inspired a prophet。 Empedocles appears to have been at once an observer and a dreamer。 He is credited with noting that the pressure of air will sustain the weight of water in an inverted tube； with divining； without the possibility of proof； that light has actual motion in space； and with asserting that centrifugal motion must keep the heavens from falling。 He is credited with a great sanitary feat in the draining of a marsh； and his knowledge of medicine was held to be supernatural。 Fortunately； some fragments of the writings of Empedocles have come down to us； enabling us to judge at first hand as to part of his doctrines； while still more is known through the references made to him by Plato； Aristotle； and other commentators。 Empedocles was a poet whose verses stood the test of criticism。 In this regard he is in a like position with Parmenides； but in neither case are the preserved fragments sufficient to enable us fully to estimate their author's scientific attainments。 Philosophical writings are obscure enough at the best； and they perforce become doubly so when expressed in verse。 Yet there are certain passages of Empedocles that are unequivocal and full of interest。 Perhaps the most important conception which the works of Empedocles reveal to us is the denial of anthropomorphism as applied to deity。 We have seen how early the anthropomorphic conception was developed and how closely it was all along clung to； to shake the mind free from it then was a remarkable feat； in accomplishing which Empedocles took a long step in the direction of rationalism。 His conception is paralleled by that of another physician； Alcmaeon； of Proton； who contende