or from the grounds was very dramatic。 He was enthusiastically applauded and a band preceded his carriage。
For some reason I never had such a success as in addressing that audience。 Commencing with a story； which was new and effective； I continued for two hours without apparently losing an auditor。
Upon my return to the hotel I found the senator very indignant。 He said that he had gone to the Opera House with the committee； that； of course； no meeting had been advertised there； but a band had been placed on the balcony to play； as if it were a dime museum attraction inside； that a few farmers' wives had straggled in to have an opportunity to partake from their baskets their luncheons； and that he had left the Opera House and returned to the hotel。 The committee coming in and narrating what had occurred at the Fair Grounds； did not help his imperious temper。 The committee begged for a large meeting； which was to be held in the evening； but Conkling refused and ordered me to do the same； and we left on the first train。 The cordial relations which had existed up to that time were somehow severed and he became very hostile。
General Grant； as president； of course； never had had experience or opportunity to know anything of practical politics。 It was said that prior to his election he had never voted but once； and that was before the war； when he voted the Democratic ticket for James Buchanan。
All the senators； representatives； and public men who began to press around him； seeking the appointment to office of their friends； were unknown to him personalIy。 He decided rapidly whom among them he could trust； and once having arrived at that conclusion； his decision was irrevocable。 He would stand by a friend； without regard to its effect upon himself； to the last ditch。
Of course； each of the two United States senators； Conkling and Fenton； wanted his exclusive favor。 It is impossible to conceive of two men so totally different in every characteristic。 Grant liked Conkling as much as he disliked Fenton。 The result was that he transferred the federal patronage of the State to Senator Conkling。
Conkling was a born leader； very autocratic and dictatorial。 He immediately began to remove Fenton officials and to replace them with members of his own organization。 As there was no civil service at that time and public officers were necessarily active politicians； Senator Conkling in a few years destroyed the organization which Fenton had built up as governor； and became master of the Republican party in the State。
The test came at the State convention at Saratoga。 Senator Conkling at that time had become hostile to me； why I do not know； nor could his friends； who were most of them mine also； find out。 He directed that I must not be elected a delegate to the convention。 The collector of the port of New York； in order to make that decree effective； filled my district in Westchester County with appointees from the Custom House。
Patronage； when its control is subject to a popular vote； is a boomerang。 The appointment of a citizen in a town arouses the anger of many others who think they are more deserving。 I appealed to the farmers with the simple question whether old Westchester should be controlled by federal authority in a purely State matter of their own。 The result of the appeal was overwhelming； and when the district convention met； the Custom House did not have a single delegate。
The leader of the Custom House crowd came to me and said： 〃This is a matter of bread…and…butter and living with us。 It is nothing to you。 These delegates are against us and for you at the convention。 Now； we have devised a plan to save our lives。 It is that the three delegates elected shall all be friends of yours。 You shall apparently be defeated。 A resolution will be passed that if either delegate fails to attend or resigns； the other two may fill the vacancy。 One of these will resign when the convention meets and you will be substituted in his place。 In the meantime we will send out through the Associated Press that you have been defeated。〃 I did not have the heart to see these poor fellows dismissed from their employment； and I assented to the proposition。
When we arrived at the convention Governor Cornell； then State chairman； called to order。 I arose to make a motion； when he announced： 〃You； sir； are not a member of this convention。〃 My credentials； however； under the arrangement made in Westchester； convinced him that he was misinformed。 The Conkling side selected for their chairman Andrew D。 White； and the other side selected me。 Upon careful canvass of the votes we had a clear majority。
There were several delegations which were controIled by federal office…holders。 It is at this point that patronage becomes overwhelmingly effective。 Several of those office…holders were shown telegrams from Washington； which meant their removal unless they did as directed by Senator Conkling。 When the convention met the next day； the office…holders kept their heads on their shoulders； and my dear and valued old friend； Andrew D。 White； was elected chairman of the convention。
I asked the leader of the federal crowd from Westchester how he explained my getting into the convention。 〃Oh；〃 he said； 〃that was easy。 Our people gained so many delegates by offers of patronage and threats of removal that when I told them you had bought my delegates away from me； they believed it without question； and we are all safe in our places in the Custom House。〃 My success was entirely due to the farmers' indignation at federal dictation； and the campaign did not cost me a dollar。
Roscoe Conkling was created by nature for a great career。 That he missed it was entirely his own fault。 Physically he was the handsomest man of his time。 His mental equipment nearly approached genius。 He was industrious to a degree。 His oratorical gifts were of the highest order； and he was a debater of rare power and resources。 But his intolerable egotism deprived him of vision necessary for supreme leadership。 With all his oratorical power and his talent in debate； he made little impression upon the country and none upon posterity。 His position in the Senate was a masterful one； and on the platform most attractive； but none of his speeches appear in the schoolbooks or in the collections of great orations。 The reason was that his wonderful gifts were wholly devoted to partisan discussions and local issues。
His friends regarded his philippic against George W。 Curtis at the Republican State convention at Rochester as the high…water mark of his oratory。 I sat in the seat next to Mr。 Curtis when Conkling delivered his famous attack。 His admirers thought this the best speech he ever made； and it certainly was a fine effort； emphasized by oratory of a high order； and it was received by them with the wildest enthusiasm and applause。
The assault upon Mr。 Curtis was exceedingly bitter； the denunciation very severe； and every resource of sarcasm； of which Mr。 Conkling was past master； was poured upon the victim。 His bitterness was caused by Mr。 Curtis's free criticism of him on various occasions。 The speech lasted two hours； and it was curious to note its effect upon Mr。 Curtis。 Under the rules which the convention had adopted； he could not reply； so he had to sit and take it。 The only feeling or evidence of being hurt by his punishment was in exclamations at different points made by his assailant。 They were： 〃Remarkable！〃 〃Extraordinary！〃 〃What an exhibition！〃 〃Bad temper！〃 〃Very bad temper！〃
In the long controversy between them Mr。 Curtis had the advantages which the journalist always possesses。 The orator has one opportunity on the platform and the publication the next day in the press。 The editorand Mr。 Curtis was at that time editor of Harper's Weeklycan return every Saturday and have an exclusive hearing by an audience limited only by the circulation of his newspaper and the quotations from it by journalistic friends。
The speech illustrated ConkIing's methods of preparation。 I used to hear from the senator's friends very frequently that he had added another phrase to his characterization of Curtis。 While he was a ready debater； yet for an effort of this kind he would sometimes devote a year to going frequently over the ground； and in each repetition produce new epigrams； quotable phrases； and characterizations。
There used to be an employee of the State committee named Lawrence。 He was a man of a good deal of receptive intelligence and worshipped the senator。 Mr。 Conkling discovered this quality and used Lawrence as a target or listening…post。 I have often had Lawrence come to my office and say： 〃I had a great night。 The senator talked to me or made speeches to me until nearly morning。〃 He told me that he had heard every word of the Curtis philippic many times。
Lawrence told me of another instance of Conkling's preparation for a great effort。 When he was preparing the speech； which was to bring his friends who had been disappointed at the convention to the support of General Garfield； he summoned Lawrence for clerical work at his home。 Lawrence said that the senator would write or dictate； and then correct until he was satisfied with the effort； and that this took considerable time。 When it was completed he would take long walks into the country； and in these walks recite the whole or part of his speech until he was perfect master of it。
This speech took four hours in delivery in New York； and he held the audience throughout this long period。 John Reed； one of the editors of the New York Times； told me that he sat on the stage near Conkling and had in his hands the proofs which had been set up in advance and which filled ten columns of his paper。 He said that the senator neither omitted nor interpolated a word from the beginning to the end。 He would frequently refer apparently to notes on his cuffs； or little memoranda； not that he needed them； but it was the orator's always successful effort to create impression that his speech is extemporaneous； and the audience much prefer a speech which they think is such。
Senator Conkling held an important position in a critical period of our country's history。 If his gre