“What is it？” he said； almost in a whisper。
At the touch of his hand； she began to tremble。 It was going to happen now； just as she had dreamed it。 A thousand incoherent thoughts shot through her mind； and she could not catch a single one to mold into a word。 She could only shake and look up into his face。 Why didn’t he speak？
“What is it？” he repeated。 “A secret to tell me？”
Suddenly she found her tongue and just as suddenly all the years of Ellen’s teachings fell away； and the forthright Irish blood of Gerald spoke from his daughter’s lips。
“Yes—a secret I love you。”
For an instance there was a silence so acute it seemed that neither of them even breathed。 Then the trembling fell away from her； as happiness and pride surged through her。 Why hadn’t she done this before？ How much simpler than all the ladylike maneuverings she had been taught。 And then her eyes sought his。
There was a look of consternation in them； of incredulity and something more—what was it？ Yes； Gerald had looked that way the day his pet hunter had broken his leg and he had had to shoot him。 Why did she have to think of that now？ Such a silly thought。 And why did Ashley look so oddly and say nothing？ Then something like a well…trained mask came down over his face and he smiled gallantly。
“Isn’t it enough that you’ve collected every other man’s heart here today？” he said； with the old； teasing； caressing note in his voice。 “Do you want to make it unanimous？ Well； you’ve always had my heart； you know。 You cut your teeth on it。”
Something was wrong—all wrong！ This was not the way she had planned it。 Through the mad tearing of ideas round and round in her brain； one was beginning to take form。 Somehow—for some reason—Ashley was acting as if he thought she was just flirting with him。 But he knew differently。 She knew he did。
“Ashley—Ashley—tell me—you must—oh； don’t tease me now！ Have I your heart？ Oh； my dear； I lo—”
His hand went across her lips； swiftly。 The mask was gone。
“You must not say these things； Scarlett！ You mustn’t。 You don’t mean them。 You’ll hate yourself for saying them； and you’ll hate me for hearing them！”
She jerked her head away。 A hot swift current was running through her。
“I couldn’t ever hate you。 I tell you I love you and I know you must care about me because—” She stopped。 Never before had she seen so much misery in anyone’s face。 “Ashley； do you care—you do； don’t you？”
“Yes；” he said dully。 “I care。”
If he had said he loathed her； she could not have been more frightened。 She plucked at his sleeve； speechless。
“Scarlett；” he said； “can’t we go away and forget that we have ever said these things？”
“No；” she whispered。 “I can’t。 What do you mean？ Don’t you want to—to marry me？”
He replied； I’m going to marry Melanie。”
Somehow she found that she was sitting on the low velvet chair and Ashley； on the hassock at her feet； was holding both her hands in his； in a hard grip。 He was saying things—things that made no sense。 Her mind was quite blank； quite empty of all the thoughts that had surged through it only a moment before； and his words made no more impression than rain on glass。 They fell on unhearing ears； words that were swift and tender and full of pity； like a father speaking to a hurt child。
The sound of Melanie’s name caught in her consciousness and she looked into his crystal…gray eyes。 She saw in them the old remoteness that had always baffled her—and a look of self…hatred。
“Father is to announce the engagement tonight。 We are to be married soon。 I should have told you； but I thought you knew。 I thought everyone knew—had known for years。 I never dreamed that you— You’ve so many beaux。 I thought Stuart—”
Life and feeling and comprehension were beginning to flow back into her。
“But you just said you cared for me。”
His warm hands hurt hers。
“My dear； must you make me say things that will hurt you？”
Her silence pressed him on。
“How can I make you see these things； my dear。 You who are so young and unthinking that you do not know what marriage means。”
“I know I love you。”
“Love isn’t enough to make a successful marriage when two people are as different as we are。 You would want all of a man； Scarlett； his body； his heart； his soul； his thoughts。 And if you did not have them； you would be miserable。 And I couldn’t give you all of me。 I couldn’t give all of me to anyone。 And I would not want an of your mind and your soul。 And you would be hurt； and then you would come to hate me—how bitterly！ You would hate the books I read and the music I loved； because they took me away from you even for a moment And I—perhaps I—”
“Do you love her？”
“She is like me； part of my blood； and we understand each other。 Scarlett！ Scarlett！ Can’t I make you see that a marriage can’t go on in any sort of peace unless the two people are alike？”
Some one else had said that： “Like must marry like or there’ll be no happiness。” Who was it？ It seemed a million years since she had heard that； but it still did not make sense。
“But you said you cared。”
“I shouldn’t have said it。”
Somewhere in her brain； a slow fire rose and rage began to blot out everything else。
“Well； having been cad enough to say it—”
His face went white。
“I was a cad to say it； as I’m going to marry Melanie。 I did you a wrong and Melanie a greater one。 I should not have said it； for I knew you wouldn’t understand。 How could I help caring for you—you who have all the passion for life that I have not？ You who can love and hate with a violence impossible to me？ Why you are as elemental as fire and wind and wild things and I—”
She thought of Melanie and saw suddenly her quiet brown eyes with their far…off look； her placid little hands in their black lace mitts； her gentle silences。 And then her rage broke； the same rage that drove Gerald to murder and other Irish ancestors to misdeeds that cost them their necks。 There was nothing in her now of the well…bred Robillards who could bear with white silence anything the world might cast。
“Why don’t you say it； you coward！ You’re afraid to marry me！ You’d rather live with that stupid little fool who can’t open her mouth except to say ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ and raise a passel of mealy…mouthed brats just like her！ Why—”
“You must not say these things about Melanie！”
“ ‘I mustn’t’ be damned to you！ Who are you to tell me I mustn’t？ You coward； you cad； you— You made me believe you were going to marry me—”
“Be fair；” his voice pleaded。 “Did I ever—”
She did not want to be fair； although she knew what he said was true。 He had never once crossed the borders of friendliness with her and； when she thought of this fresh anger rose； the anger of hurt pride and feminine vanity。 She had run after him and he would have none of her。 He preferred a whey…faced little fool like Melanie to her。 Oh； far better that she had followed Ellen and Mammy’s precepts and never； never revealed that she even liked him—better anything than to be faced with this scorching shame！
She sprang to her feet； her hands clenched and he rose towering over her。 his face full of the mute misery of one forced to face realities when realities are agonies。
“I shall hate you till I die； you cad—you lowdown—lowdown—” What was the word she wanted？ She could not think of any word bad enough。
“Scarlett—please—”
He put out his hand toward her and； as he did； she slapped him across the face with all the strength she had。 The noise cracked like a whip in the still room and suddenly her rage was gone； and there was desolation in her heart。
The red mark of her hand showed plainly on his white tired face。 He said nothing； but lifted her limp hand to his lips and kissed it。 Then he was gone before she could speak again； closing the door softly behind him。
She sat down again very suddenly； the reaction from her rage making her knees feel weak。 He was gone and the memory of his stricken face would haunt her till she died。
She heard the soft muffled sound of his footsteps dying away down the long hall； and the complete enormity of her actions came over her。 She had lost him forever。 Now he would hate her and every time he looked at her he would remember how she threw herself at him when he had given her no encouragement at all。
“I’m as bad as Honey Wilkes；” she thought suddenly； and remembered how everyone； and she more than anyone else； had laughed contemptuously at Honey’s forward conduct。 She saw Honey’s awkward wigglings and heard her silly titters as she hung onto boys’ arms； and the thought stung her to new rage； rage at herself； at Ashley； at the world。 Because she hated herself； she hated them all with the fury of the thwarted and humiliated love of sixteen。 Only a little true tenderness had been mixed into her love。 Mostly it had been compounded out of vanity and complacent confidence in her own charms。 Now she had lost and； greater than her sense of loss； was the fear that she had made a public spectacle of herself。 Had she been as obvious as Honey？ Was everyone laughing at her？ She began to shake at the thought。
Her hand dropped to a little table beside her； fingering a tiny china rose…bowl on which two china cherubs smirked。 The room was so still she almost screamed to break the silence。 She must do something or go mad。 She picked up the bowl and hurled it viciously across the room toward the fireplace。 It barely cleared the tall back of the sofa and splintered with a little crash against the marble mantelpiece。
“This；” said a voice from the depths of the sofa； “is too much。”
Nothing had ever startled or frightened her so much； and her mouth went too dry for her to utter a sound。 She caught hold of the back of the chair； her knees going weak under her； as Rhett Butler rose from the sofa where he had been lying and made her a bow of exaggerated politeness。
“It is bad enough to have an afternoon nap disturbed by such a passage as I’ve been forced to hear； but why should my life be endangered？”
He was real。 He wasn’t a ghost。 But； saints preserve us； he had heard everything！ She rallied her forces into a